Pass the Espresso on the Left Hand Side: Understanding Uneven Espresso Flow

Watching the World Barista Championship, we noticed something intriguing: despite the precision and skill of the baristas, many espressos didn’t flow evenly from both spouts. It raised a question we’ve often pondered: why does this happen? Is it the barista’s technique, machine design, or something else entirely? Today, let’s delve into our experiments at The Coffee Blog to shed light on this espresso mystery.

The Setup: Unveiling the Mechanics

To get to the bottom of uneven espresso flow, we set up a series of controlled experiments at Puerto Blest, a top specialty roastery in Buenos Aires. We used a Black Eagle Maverick espresso machine, ensuring it was in pristine condition to eliminate any equipment bias. Our coffee of choice was a consistent washed SL-28 from Finca Las Nubes in El Salvador, a stable base for our tests.

Experiment Protocol

We meticulously followed a protocol:

• Dose and Yield: 18 grams dose, 45 grams yield in 28 seconds.
• Machine Level: Confirmed using a spirit level under the grouphead.
• Tamping: Varied between flat and angled, up to 15 degrees.
• Machine Tilt: Adjusted by lifting the left side 1 cm to simulate uneven setup.
• Grind Setting: Adjusted for shot time consistency across tests.

Observations: What We Discovered

Across our experiments, several key findings emerged:

1. Tamping and Flow: Contrary to common belief, tamping angle (up to 15 degrees) had negligible impact on which spout released espresso first or how evenly it flowed.
2. Machine Tilt: Tilting the machine by lifting one side did influence the espresso distribution. The side raised tended to release more espresso. Though the difference was minimal and often less than a gram.
3. Shot Timing: Despite adjustments, even when shots dropped simultaneously. We observed up to a 3-gram difference in espresso yield between the two spouts.
4. Taste Differences: Tasting revealed slight variations in body and acidity between the cups that caught the first drops versus the second, suggesting sensory differences even with similar extraction metrics.

Insights and Implications

Our findings challenge conventional wisdom:

• Barista Technique: Uneven flow isn’t necessarily indicative of poor tamping or distribution. Even skilled baristas can’t completely control this aspect due to inherent design limitations.
• Machine Design: While slight tilting affects flow, the impact isn’t substantial enough to be solely blame for uneven shots.
• Sensory Experience: The first drops affect flavor intensity. Judges at competitions like the World Barista Championship note these differences, impacting sensory scoring.

Practical Takeaways for Baristas

For those striving for consistent espresso quality:

• Check Equipment: Ensure your machine is level, dispersion screens are clean, and portafilter integrity is intact.
• Accept Variability: Minor differences between shots are normal. Educate customers on this natural variation.
• Competition Tips: In competitions, where every point counts, minimizing flow differences becomes critical. Technical judges note discrepancies, affecting scores under ‘Consistent dosing and tamping.’

Looking Ahead

While our experiments shed light on the mechanics behind uneven espresso flow, there’s still much to explore—especially when it comes to brew pressure and control. Tools like the AeroPress offer a more hands-on way to manipulate pressure, often sidestepping the issue of uneven dual-spout flow altogether. For baristas seeking absolute control over their pour technique, pairing that understanding with tools like the swan neck kettle can also yield measurable improvements in extraction consistency—especially for pour-over or bloom-heavy brewing styles.

Subscribe to TCB for More Insights

Stay updated with the latest from The Coffee Blog. Subscribe to our newsletter for expert tips, brewing guides, and gear breakdowns. Whether you’re pulling a shot on a competition-grade machine or brewing with a travel-friendly AeroPress, we’ve got the insights to help you master your craft.

Final Thoughts

Understanding why espresso flows unevenly from the spouts involves a blend of science, observation, and practical know-how. While perfecting every shot may remain just out of reach, recognizing and managing these variables empowers baristas to improve flavor, consistency, and customer experience. Join us at The Coffee Blog as we continue to unravel coffee’s complexities—one brew at a time, one pour at a time.